Hibachi Sauces: Yum Yum, Ginger, Mustard and Garlic Butter

What hibachi sauce means at a Japanese steakhouse: the three dipping sauces, the garlic butter the chef cooks with, what goes with what, and how much to make.

Photo pending: Three small bowls of hibachi dipping sauces — yum yum, ginger and mustard — next to a griddle

At a Japanese steakhouse in the United States, "hibachi sauce" usually means one of the dipping sauces set next to your plate: the creamy pink-orange yum yum sauce, a thin brown ginger sauce and, in many restaurants, a creamy mustard sauce. The sauce the chef actually cooks with is different — garlic butter and soy sauce, added on the griddle at the end. All four are quick to make at home, and three of them taste better made ahead.

The hibachi sauces at a glance

SauceWhat it isTastesReady inKeeps
Yum yum sauceMayonnaise, tomato paste, melted butter, rice vinegar, paprikaCreamy, sweet, mild35 min (5 hands-on)Up to 4 days, refrigerated
Ginger sauceRaw onion and fresh ginger blended with soy sauce, rice vinegar and lemonThin, tangy, sharp40 min (10 hands-on)Up to 4 days, refrigerated
Mustard sauceMustard powder, soy sauce, heavy cream, toasted sesameCreamy with a hot-mustard kick40 min (10 hands-on)Up to 4 days, refrigerated
Garlic butterButter, minced garlic and soy sauce, straight into the panRich, savory1 to 2 min, at the end of cookingMade fresh in the pan

Which sauce goes with what

Every plate gets every sauce, so there is no wrong answer — but each one has a job:

  • Steak: ginger sauce or mustard sauce. The acid and the mustard heat cut through the butter.
  • Chicken and shrimp: yum yum sauce, with ginger sauce if you want something lighter.
  • Vegetables: ginger sauce.
  • Fried rice and noodles: yum yum sauce. The rice is already seasoned with garlic butter and soy sauce, so it needs richness, not salt.

Yum yum sauce

The best known of the three, and the one most people mean by "hibachi sauce": mayonnaise, a little tomato paste for color, melted butter and rice vinegar, whisked in five minutes and rested for half an hour. Get the yum yum sauce recipe.

Ginger sauce

The tangy, salty one. Raw onion and fresh ginger are pulsed with soy sauce, rice vinegar and lemon until finely chopped but not smooth, then chilled so the onion mellows. It is the lightest of the three and the best with steak and vegetables. Get the hibachi ginger sauce recipe.

Mustard sauce

The creamy one with a kick. Mustard powder is mixed with cold water and left for ten minutes to develop its heat, then whisked with soy sauce, heavy cream and toasted sesame. No cooking. Get the hibachi mustard sauce recipe.

Hibachi garlic butter: the sauce the chef cooks with

The flavor people try to recreate at home is mostly not a dipping sauce at all. It is butter, garlic and soy sauce, added to the griddle after the sear, over lower heat, so the garlic turns fragrant instead of burning. Our recipes use the same proportions throughout:

  • Hibachi chicken and hibachi steak: 2 tablespoons of butter and 3 cloves of garlic for four servings, with soy sauce and a squeeze of lemon tossed in during the last minute.
  • Hibachi fried rice: the same 2 tablespoons of butter mashed with 3 cloves of garlic, half added with the rice and half with the soy sauce at the end.

There is no separate recipe to follow: make it in the pan, as the last step of whatever you are cooking.

How much to make for a party

Each of our sauce recipes counts a serving as about 2 tablespoons per person. One batch of yum yum sauce covers 8 people, and one batch each of ginger and mustard sauce covers 6. For a dozen guests, double all three.

Make the whole tray ahead

All three dipping sauces improve after resting, so they are the part of a hibachi night to do early — the day before, or before you start cooking:

  1. Ginger sauce first: the raw onion needs at least half an hour in the refrigerator to soften.
  2. Mustard sauce next: ten minutes for the mustard to bloom, then into the refrigerator.
  3. Yum yum sauce last, or whenever: it only needs half an hour.

Serve them cold, in small bowls or squeeze bottles, and put them back in the refrigerator when the meal is over. Food that sits out longer than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90°F, should be thrown away.

Where these sauces come from

Only one of the three dipping sauces is built from a traditional Japanese pantry, and it is the ginger one. Mayonnaise, tomato, dairy and sugar are the adaptations that made griddle cooking an American restaurant meal. The full story, sauce by sauce, is in the teppanyaki menu guide.

Sources

FAQ

What is hibachi sauce called?
There is no single hibachi sauce. The creamy pink-orange one is usually called yum yum sauce, and also white sauce, shrimp sauce or sakura sauce. The thin brown one is ginger sauce, and the pale creamy one served with steak is mustard sauce.
What sauce do hibachi chefs cook with?
Garlic butter and soy sauce, added at the end of cooking so the garlic turns fragrant without burning. Our chicken and steak recipes add a squeeze of lemon at the same moment. The dipping sauces are for the table, not the griddle.
Which hibachi sauce goes with steak?
Ginger sauce and mustard sauce are the classic pair for steak: one tangy and sharp, the other creamy and hot. Yum yum sauce works with everything, so most people keep it for the rice and the shrimp.
How long do homemade hibachi sauces keep?
Our yum yum, ginger and mustard sauces all keep up to 4 days in sealed jars in the refrigerator, and none should sit out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90°F. Garlic butter is made in the pan, so there is nothing to store.